Foreclosure attorneys in Bay Shore: ranked picks
Bay Shore sits at the center of Suffolk County's foreclosure and bankruptcy court traffic, and the attorneys here range from full-service immigration and family law shops that also handle foreclosure defense to firms built specifically around loan modification and short sales. The list below is ranked using our methodology, which weighs rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment together rather than star rating alone.
Suffolk County's foreclosure timeline runs through mandatory settlement conferences, so homeowners here are usually looking for someone who can move fast on loan modification paperwork or represent them at conference dates, not just file paperwork after the fact. A few firms below lean toward bankruptcy and mortgage hardship work rather than courtroom foreclosure defense, worth checking before you call.
6 businesses, scored on rating, review volume, recency, sentiment and listing completeness. How we score › · View on map ›
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Palacios Law Group | 91 | 4.9 (144) | — | Bilingual clients, guided process |
| 2 | Law Office of Anadel Canale | 90 | 5 (86) | — | Foreclosure defense, bankruptcy |
| 3 | The Brooke Law Firm | 80 | 4.9 (76) | — | Mortgage modification, plain-English advice |
| 4 | Siben & Siben LLP | 73 | 4.1 (123) | — | Established firm, no-fault cases |
| 5 | A & C Short Sale LLC | 59 | 5 (2) | — | Short sales, flat-fee loan mods |
| 6 | Mortgage Modification Preparation Service | 22 | — | — | Not yet reviewed |
Ranked picks

Palacios Law Group
score 91/100A 4.9-star average across 144 reviews with praise for bilingual staff who walk clients through each step of complex cases.

Law Office of Anadel Canale
score 90/100Perfect 5-star rating across 86 reviews, with reviewers crediting her for preventing home loss and explaining every step clearly.

The Brooke Law Firm
score 80/100Nearly all reviewers praise John Brooke's calm, clear explanations of bankruptcy and foreclosure defense, despite one report of a missed-appointment delay.

Siben & Siben LLP
score 73/100A Bay Shore fixture since 1995 with quick settlements for most clients, though some reviewers flagged inconsistent follow-up on complex cases.

A & C Short Sale LLC
score 59/100Two reviewers praised professional, results-focused short sale handling, though recent review activity is limited.

Mortgage Modification Preparation Service
score 22/100No reviews are on record yet, so there isn't enough data to gauge client experience here.