Foreclosure attorneys in Brentwood: ranked picks
Brentwood homeowners facing foreclosure, loan modification, or a tight closing timeline have several Islip-area firms to choose from, and the right fit depends on whether you need aggressive negotiation, a steady hand through paperwork, or a lawyer who'll go to trial if it comes to that. The picks below are ranked using our methodology, which weighs rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment together rather than star rating alone.
Many of these firms serve the wider Islip Metro rather than a single town, and several handle both foreclosure defense and the real estate closings that often follow a loan modification or short sale, useful if you need one attorney to carry a case from default through to a resolved sale.
11 businesses, scored on rating, review volume, recency, sentiment and listing completeness. How we score › · View on map ›
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sugarman Law PC | 85 | 5 (34) | — | Real estate closings |
| 2 | Kinzer & Musikar Attorneys At Law | 73 | 4.8 (20) | — | Foreclosure & bankruptcy |
| 3 | O'Shea & Associates Law Firm PC | 69 | 5 (3) | — | Fast-moving closings |
| 4 | John A Reno Esq. | 68 | 4.7 (15) | — | Loan modification |
| 5 | The Fisher Law Firm | 67 | 5 (2) | — | Foreclosure prevention |
| 6 | Leonick Law P.L.L.C. | 67 | 5 (11) | — | Personalized guidance |
| 7 | Misiano Law | 63 | 4.2 (6) | — | Courtroom litigation |
| 8 | Howard E. Knispel, P.C. | 59 | 4.3 (6) | — | Complex case management |
| 9 | Sandyford Resources | 56 | 4 (4) | — | loan modification |
| 10 | Anthony P. Gallo PC | 55 | 4 (4) | — | loan modification |
| 11 | Allison Boyd, Esq. | 26 | — | — | foreclosure defense litigation |
Ranked picks
Sugarman Law PC
score 85/100Top composite score on a perfect 5.0 rating across 34 reviews, with Shari Sugarman's team praised for calm, plain-language handling of transactions.
Kinzer & Musikar Attorneys At Law
score 73/100Michael Kinzer gets consistent praise for resolving foreclosure and bankruptcy cases through negotiation and explaining the process clearly.
O'Shea & Associates Law Firm PC
score 69/100A perfect rating from a small but recent set of reviewers who call Joe, Alex, and Mike LiPetri responsive and well organized.
John A Reno Esq.
score 68/100Thirty years of real estate and foreclosure experience with reviewers citing fair pricing, though a few older reviews mention slow callbacks.
The Fisher Law Firm
score 67/100Charles handled foreclosure prevention alongside home sales for reviewers who noted paperwork prepared ahead of schedule and on-time closings.
Leonick Law P.L.L.C.
score 67/100All 11 reviews are five-star, with Jim Leonick singled out for clear explanations that leave clients feeling heard through house sales and legal matters.
Misiano Law
score 63/100Long-term clients point to decades of trial wins, though one detailed complaint about a failed closing and poor follow-up is worth weighing.
Howard E. Knispel, P.C.
score 59/100Practicing since 1989 with attentive, court-tested handling of complex cases, despite one older report of a dismissive interaction.
Sandyford Resources
score 56/100Three reviewers praised Shawn and the team for knowledgeable, helpful foreclosure assistance at no upfront cost and fast service.
Anthony P. Gallo PC
score 55/100Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Allison Boyd, Esq.
score 26/100Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.