Most clients experienced swift case resolution and felt heard by staff who called back promptly and explained each step. A smaller group reported uneven attention, with some attorneys showing up unprepared or dismissive, particularly in complex or lower-value cases; one reviewer also noted the firm prioritized its own fees over client outcomes.
Siben & Siben is an established Bay Shore firm with named attorneys including Mark, Larry, Jonathan Rudner, and paralegal Dominique Blue. Praised clients highlight long tenures (some since 1995) and no-fault expertise. Complaints cluster around inconsistent case management when clients have complex medical histories or require sustained advocacy, suggesting case-load or screening challenges rather than universal dysfunction.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
John Brooke and his firm help clients navigate bankruptcy, mortgage modification, and foreclosure defense. Nearly all reviewers praise his calm demeanor, prompt replies, and ability to explain complicated steps clearly. One client reported a 15-minute wait without acknowledgment and no apology or rescheduling call afterward, a stark outlier against overwhelming positive feedback.
Reviewers consistently praise the attorneys and staff for knowledgeable guidance, responsiveness, and genuine care throughout legal matters. The firm earns particular credit for bilingual staff, especially Nicolle, whose professionalism and attention to detail help clients feel supported through what could otherwise feel overwhelming. Nicole and Nicolle (staff members) appear repeatedly as standouts: they answer questions promptly, communicate clearly in both Spanish and English, stay organized, and make clients feel heard. Reviewers report being guided step-by-step through their cases and leaving satisfied with outcomes across immigration, personal injury, and family law matters.
Last updated 2026-08-27