Foreclosure attorneys in West Islip: top picks
West Islip homeowners dealing with foreclosure or loan modification have a handful of Babylon-area firms to choose from. This list draws on client reviews and outcomes, following our methodology, to show who actually delivers when a home is on the line.
Most West Islip foreclosure cases route through Suffolk County court, and local clients often need loan modification help or short-sale negotiation alongside standard foreclosure defense.
13 businesses, scored on rating, review volume, recency, sentiment and listing completeness. How we score › · View on map ›
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Campasano Law, P.C. || Estate Planning and Real Estate Attorney in West Islip | 87 | 5 (47) | — | loan modification |
| 2 | John Weber, Esq | 84 | 4.9 (84) | — | free consultation |
| 3 | Law Office of Ronald D. Weiss, P.C. | 82 | 5 (19) | — | foreclosure defense litigation |
| 4 | George E. Patsis, PLLC | 81 | 4.6 (50) | — | foreclosure defense litigation |
| 5 | Law Office of Melissa D. Mohan PLLC | 78 | 5 (25) | — | real estate closing |
| 6 | Fine Law Offices | 75 | 4.4 (30) | — | Last-resort foreclosure defense |
| 7 | Long Island Eviction Law Firm, PLLC | 75 | 4.3 (38) | — | Landlords, fast filings |
| 8 | Phillips, Artura & Cox, Attorneys at Law | 69 | 4.2 (49) | — | foreclosure defense litigation |
| 9 | The Law Office of Michael A. Kofsky, PLLC | 65 | 4.5 (15) | — | foreclosure defense litigation |
| 10 | Clark's Laws PC | 62 | 3.9 (19) | — | Long-term clients, short sales |
| 11 | Mikel J. Hoffman Attorney at Law | 59 | 4.4 (12) | — | Real estate and estate planning |
| 12 | Glenn T. Nugent Law | 56 | 3.2 (5) | — | foreclosure defense litigation |
| 13 | Reilly Like Tenety & Hinrichs Law LLP | 54 | 5 (2) | — | Property tax and general counsel |
Ranked picks
Campasano Law, P.C. || Estate Planning and Real Estate Attorney in West Islip
score 87/100Vincent Campasano and his team earn five-star ratings for real estate closings by staying responsive, patient, and attentive through every step.
John Weber, Esq
score 84/100Most clients praise John Weber for accessibility, honest advice, and calm support through bankruptcy and real estate matters.
Law Office of Ronald D. Weiss, P.C.
score 82/100Clients consistently credit named staff-Nicole, Ivan, Rose, Gissette, Luis, Stephanie, and others-for staying in close contact, explaining options plainly, and fighting hard in court.
George E. Patsis, PLLC
score 81/100George Patsis and his team combine deep legal knowledge with genuine care for clients facing complex matters.
Law Office of Melissa D. Mohan PLLC
score 78/100Across 25 five-star reviews, Melissa D.
Fine Law Offices
score 75/100Clients repeatedly say Fine Law saved homes days before foreclosure and won loan modifications after other attorneys failed.
Long Island Eviction Law Firm, PLLC
score 75/100Praised for quick case progression and upfront pricing, though a few clients report friction over refunds and billing.
Phillips, Artura & Cox, Attorneys at Law
score 69/100Many reviewers describe Richard Artura as thoughtful and deeply engaged with their cases, taking time to explain complex legal matters in understandable terms.
The Law Office of Michael A. Kofsky, PLLC
score 65/100Most clients praise Michael Kofsky's attention to detail, availability, and straightforward fees on business formation and real estate work.
Clark's Laws PC
score 62/100Jim Clark earns loyalty for patient guidance through crisis, but recent reviews flag unresponsiveness and abandoned deals.
Mikel J. Hoffman Attorney at Law
score 59/100Over 25 years of hands-on service, though one case shows record-keeping gaps can go unaddressed.
Glenn T. Nugent Law
score 56/100One long-term client praised Nugent's clarity and experience, but multiple reviewers reported poor communication, confusing bills, and a dismissive attitude.
Reilly Like Tenety & Hinrichs Law LLP
score 54/100A small but perfect-rated Babylon firm serving the area since 1950, with limited review volume so far.