Best foreclosure attorneys in Babylon
These are the top 7 foreclosure attorneys in Babylon, ranked by an earned composite score built from rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment (see our methodology). Most of these firms handle the full range of foreclosure defense work, from loan modification to short sales, so this list ranks them head to head rather than splitting them by specialty.
If you need help with a real estate closing or title issue rather than foreclosure defense, that's a separate specialty covered on our best real estate & title closing page. The order here reflects each firm's composite score, weighing how consistently and recently clients report good outcomes.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to foreclosure attorney, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fine Law Offices | 75 | 4.4 (30) | — | Turning around cases other lawyers gave up on |
| 2 | Long Island Eviction Law Firm, PLLC | 75 | 4.3 (38) | — | Landlords who need fast, no-surprise case handling |
| 3 | Save My Home | 64 | 5 (2) | — | Loan modification and short-sale relief |
| 4 | Clark's Laws PC | 62 | 3.9 (19) | — | Long-time clients working a complex, multi-service case |
| 5 | Mikel J. Hoffman Attorney at Law | 59 | 4.4 (12) | — | Established attorney for real estate, wills, and trusts alongside foreclosure |
| 6 | BLS Network Babylon: Bankruptcy & Real Estate Attorney’s | 58 | 5 (1) | — | Combined bankruptcy and real estate foreclosure matters |
| 7 | Reilly Like Tenety & Hinrichs Law LLP | 54 | 5 (2) | — | Long-established local firm with tax reduction know-how |
Ranked picks
Fine Law Offices
Why it ranks first
Fine Law Offices earns its top spot on a steady run of clients who came to the firm after another attorney failed them, including a loan modification secured years after the original case stalled and a home saved days before a scheduled foreclosure. Angela Sarvis and Phil get called out repeatedly for staying in close contact and walking clients through each legal step in plain terms.
Pros
- Track record of saving homes close to the foreclosure deadline
- Clear, step-by-step explanations of the legal process
- Free initial consultation
- Described as compassionate during a stressful process
Watch out: A couple of older reviews, from around six years ago, describe money paid with no results or follow-through; the firm's more recent record looks much stronger.
Services: real estate closing, foreclosure defense litigation, loan modification, free consultation
Long Island Eviction Law Firm, PLLC
Why it ranks second
This firm draws consistent praise for moving eviction and foreclosure-adjacent cases along quickly with upfront pricing and no hidden fees, and both named attorneys, James and Michelle Murtha, are cited directly for staying accessible. Review volume and recency here are strong, giving this ranking more weight than most on this list.
Pros
- Cases move quickly through filing and court dates
- Upfront retainer with no hidden fees
- Named attorneys stay directly accessible to clients
- Regular email and phone updates throughout the case
Watch out: A handful of clients describe refund pushback and inconsistent courtroom follow-through, so ask upfront how your case will be staffed if it goes to a contested hearing.
Services: real estate closing, foreclosure defense litigation, free consultation, loan modification
Save My Home
Why it ranks third
Save My Home's two reviews both describe real outcomes: one client cut a mortgage payment by $600 a month after divorce, another avoided losing his home and negotiated moving assistance through a short sale after a job loss. Both callers described the team as respectful and thorough in explaining options in plain language.
Pros
- Direct experience stopping active foreclosures
- Explains bank options in plain, non-legal language
Watch out: Only two reviews are on record, so this is a promising but thin sample compared to the firms above it.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation, real estate closing, short sale deed in lieu
Clark's Laws PC
Why it ranks fourth
Jim Clark draws loyalty from longer-standing clients who cite his patience through foreclosure and short-sale cases, with staff like Eileen and Stacee singled out for responsiveness. That said, the review record is split sharply, about two-thirds five-star against a quarter one- or two-star, driven by more recent complaints.
Pros
- Named for patience with clients under financial stress
- Staff (Eileen, Stacee) responsive on established cases
- Handles multi-service transactions (foreclosure plus short sale)
- Long-term client loyalty on record
Watch out: Recent reviews describe unresponsiveness, stalled deals, and even fraud allegations, a sharper split than anywhere else on this list, so vet current staffing before committing.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, real estate closing, free consultation, loan modification
Mikel J. Hoffman Attorney at Law
Why it ranks fifth
Mikel J. Hoffman has built 25-plus years of client relationships, and most reviewers point to hands-on availability, thorough preparation, and clear explanations across real estate, wills, and trust work. It's a smaller review base than the top picks, so weigh the one serious complaint below alongside the largely positive record.
Pros
- 25-plus years of client relationships
- Available outside normal hours, including holiday weekends
- Clear, plain-language communication
- Thorough preparation and attention to detail
Watch out: One review describes a decades-old will and trust filing error that left an estate unprotected, and says the office later declined to help fix it.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, real estate closing, free consultation, loan modification
BLS Network Babylon: Bankruptcy & Real Estate Attorney’s
Why it ranks sixth
BLS Network covers bankruptcy and real estate law alongside foreclosure work, which can help if your case involves more than one of those threads. Its lone review is a perfect five stars, but that's not enough volume yet to say much about consistency.
Pros
- Covers bankruptcy and real estate law in addition to foreclosure
- Perfect rating on its one review so far
Watch out: Only one review is on record, so there's too little data here to judge how the firm performs case to case.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, real estate closing, loan modification
Reilly Like Tenety & Hinrichs Law LLP
Why it ranks seventh
Reilly Like Tenety & Hinrichs says it has served Babylon since 1950, and its handful of reviews describe a helpful, friendly staff. The firm also lists property and commercial tax reduction work alongside its foreclosure practice.
Pros
- Long-standing local firm, established since 1950
- Staff described as helpful and friendly
Watch out: Only two reviews are on record, so there's limited detail on how foreclosure cases specifically play out here.
Services: free consultation, loan modification, real estate closing