Best real estate & title closing attorneys in Islip
This list ranks Islip attorneys for whom real estate and title closing work is a core part of their practice, scored using our methodology based on rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment.
Foreclosure defense is judged separately: see our pick for best foreclosure attorney overall. The order here reflects each firm's earned composite score for real estate and closing work specifically.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to real estate & title closing, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Law Office of Michael A. Schillinger, Esq. | 94 | 5 (285) | — | Top overall score, plain-spoken counsel |
| 2 | Campasano Law, P.C. || Estate Planning and Real Estate Attorney in West Islip | 87 | 5 (47) | — | Real estate closings, first-time buyers |
| 3 | Immigration Law Offices of David M. Sperling | 84 | 4.5 (246) | — | Immigration-adjacent legal support |
| 4 | Marra A. Kassman, Esq., P.C. | 82 | 4.8 (53) | — | Fast turnaround, flat-fee work |
| 5 | Elaine Camlet, Esq. Divorce Mediator and Real Estate Attorney | 78 | 5 (50) | — | First-time buyers wanting hand-holding |
| 6 | Concetta G. Spirio, Esq. | 73 | 4.8 (23) | — | Estate and real estate combined |
| 7 | The Law Office of Michael A. Kofsky, PLLC | 65 | 4.5 (15) | — | Straightforward, budget-conscious deals |
| 8 | Rubin-de-Cervens Andrea | 63 | 5 (6) | — | Small but attentive closings practice |
| 9 | Cassidy Romano & Love PC | 58 | 4.3 (26) | — | Extended-hours availability |
| 10 | Silverberg P.C. | 56 | 4.7 (3) | — | Personal attention, limited track record |
| 11 | Harmel & Associates PC | 50 | 4.2 (17) | — | Routine closings with backup support |
| 12 | Eric C. Ruland, Esq. | 31 | — | — | Unproven, no review history yet |
Ranked picks
Law Office of Michael A. Schillinger, Esq.
Why it ranks first
Michael Schillinger's office earns the highest composite score on this list, built on a near-perfect rating across 285 reviews. Clients describe a lawyer who explains options in plain language, stays reachable between appointments, and trains staff to match his direct, no-false-promises style.
Pros
- Explains legal options in plain language before decisions are made
- Stays available to clients between appointments
- Staff trained to mirror the same responsive, direct approach
- Transparent about realistic outcomes rather than overselling
Services: loan modification, free consultation, foreclosure defense litigation, real estate closing
Campasano Law, P.C. || Estate Planning and Real Estate Attorney in West Islip
Why it ranks second
Vincent Campasano's firm is built around real estate and estate planning, and the reviews back it up: buyers and sellers repeatedly point to his responsiveness and willingness to push back when title companies or other buyers create complications. Staff like Chris are singled out for covering nights and weekends, which matters when a closing hits a snag outside business hours.
Pros
- Responsive outside normal business hours
- Strong track record with first-time homebuyers
- Handles electronic closings smoothly
- Advocates hard when disputes come up mid-deal
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation, real estate closing
Immigration Law Offices of David M. Sperling
Why it ranks third
This firm has the largest, most consistent review base on the list, with named attorneys and paralegals repeatedly credited for shepherding clients through complex casework. The high volume and steady recency give this score more confidence than most others here, though it's worth knowing the bulk of the praise centers on immigration matters rather than closings specifically.
Pros
- Large, consistent volume of positive reviews over time
- Named staff who stay hands-on throughout a case
- Plain-language guidance through complex paperwork
- Regular check-ins rather than going quiet after signing on
Watch out: One reviewer reported weeks without a callback, a break from the otherwise consistent pattern of accessibility.
Services: loan modification, real estate closing
Marra A. Kassman, Esq., P.C.
Why it ranks fourth
Marra and Shawn Kassman's office is known for speed and upfront flat fees, with clients describing constant updates and weekend availability across traffic, landlord, and family matters. Recent reviews from the past several months show renewed responsiveness after an earlier rough patch.
Pros
- Flat-rate, transparent pricing
- Direct communication with the attorney handling the case
- Weekend availability
- Faster-than-expected case resolutions
Watch out: An older complaint noted service dipped after a staff member left, though recent reviews show that's since improved.
Services: real estate closing, loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation, free consultation
Elaine Camlet, Esq. Divorce Mediator and Real Estate Attorney
Why it ranks fifth
Elaine Camlet holds a perfect rating across her reviews, with clients describing her as detail-oriented enough to catch problems before they turn costly. She splits her practice between real estate closings and divorce mediation, and reviewers consistently say she brings the same patience to both.
Pros
- Catches potential issues before they become costly
- Patient with first-time buyers navigating an unfamiliar process
- Connects clients to outside resources like tax or appraisal help
- Every review on record gives her five stars
Watch out: Review volume and recency are lower than the top names on this list, so treat the score as a solid but smaller sample.
Services: loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation, free consultation, real estate closing
Concetta G. Spirio, Esq.
Why it ranks sixth
Concetta Spirio draws consistent praise for working across estate planning and real estate matters while keeping clients informed on both strategy and cost. Twenty-two of her twenty-three reviews are five stars, with clients noting she prioritizes their actual interests over billable hours.
Pros
- Clear communication about costs and legal strategy
- Willing to take on cases other attorneys have mishandled
- Responsive throughout the process
- Works across real estate closings and estate planning
Watch out: One review left a vague complaint with no detail attached, against an otherwise strongly positive record.
Services: real estate closing, loan modification, free consultation, foreclosure defense litigation
The Law Office of Michael A. Kofsky, PLLC
Why it ranks seventh
Most current reviews describe Michael Kofsky as detail-oriented and fairly priced on real estate and business formation work. The sentiment is mixed overall, so it's worth going in with clear expectations about communication.
Pros
- Flat-rate fees with no hidden costs
- Attentive to detail on real estate and business matters
- Available for client questions
- Straightforward explanations of the legal process
Watch out: Two reviews over two years old describe serious lapses, including abandoning a real estate closing and failing to file a probate matter after months of excuses.
Services: foreclosure defense litigation, loan modification, free consultation, real estate closing
Rubin-de-Cervens Andrea
Why it ranks eighth
Andrea Rubin-de-Cervens gets uniformly positive marks for real estate closings, with reviewers praising her speed and willingness to fight for their interests in complicated deals. The review count is small, so treat this as an early but promising signal rather than a proven track record.
Pros
- Known for protecting client money and interests
- Fast, thorough communication
Watch out: Based on a small number of reviews, so the score carries less certainty than firms with a longer track record.
Services: real estate closing, loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Cassidy Romano & Love PC
Why it ranks ninth
Cassidy Romano & Love handles a steady volume of real estate closings, with named attorneys Chanel, Peter Wagner, Andrew LoManto, and Chris Romano getting individual praise for efficiency. The firm offers seven-day availability, though a minority of reviewers describe follow-up problems worth weighing.
Pros
- Named attorneys with a real estate closings track record
- Open seven days a week
- Handles related work like foreclosure defense
- Team members proactively follow up with questions
Watch out: A smaller group of reviewers cite unreturned calls and paperwork errors that surfaced years later.
Services: real estate closing, loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation, free consultation
Silverberg P.C.
Why it ranks tenth
The handful of reviews on record describe Karl at Silverberg P.C. as a reliable, effective communicator who delivers consistent wins for clients. There simply isn't much review volume yet to size up the practice with confidence.
Pros
- Reviewers report successful outcomes
- Described as caring and client-focused
Watch out: Only a few reviews are on record, so this score should be treated as an early read rather than a settled one.
Services: loan modification, real estate closing
Harmel & Associates PC
Why it ranks #11
Most reviewers describe Harmel & Associates as responsive and smooth on real estate closings, with staff members Lara and Gloria named repeatedly as reliable points of contact. One serious incident on record pulls the overall sentiment down, so it's worth reading the full listing before relying on this firm for a high-stakes wire transfer.
Pros
- Responsive staff, particularly Lara and Gloria
- Experienced guiding first-time homebuyers
- Family-owned practice with personal attention to clients
Watch out: One detailed complaint describes a $30k wire fraud loss after the firm forwarded unverified banking details, followed by a breakdown in communication.
Services: real estate closing, loan modification, foreclosure defense litigation
Eric C. Ruland, Esq.
Why it ranks #12
Eric C. Ruland has no reviews on record, so there isn't enough client feedback yet to say how his real estate and closing work holds up in practice. He's included here on available profile data alone.
Watch out: Zero reviews on record, so there's no client sentiment to evaluate before reaching out.
Services: real estate closing, foreclosure defense litigation