Foreclosure defense litigation is the legal work of fighting a foreclosure action in court rather than simply accepting it. In New York, that almost always means representing a homeowner in a judicial foreclosure case: challenging whether the bank properly proved standing to sue, checking that notice requirements were followed, contesting robo-signed or defective mortgage assignments, and negotiating loan modifications, short sales, or settlements while the case is pending. It's different from a general real estate lawyer's closing work: this is active courtroom representation, motion practice, and often years of back-and-forth with bank counsel. Islip's 17 listed firms in this category range from solo practitioners who handle a handful of cases at a time to larger firms with dedicated foreclosure teams.
Foreclosure cases in Suffolk County move slowly and the details matter. A few things worth checking on any attorney you're considering:
Our scoring weighs factors like responsiveness, verified experience with foreclosure-specific litigation, client feedback, and transparency around fees, so you're not guessing based on a website alone. See the full ranked guide to Islip foreclosure attorneys for how each of the 17 firms compares, and read our methodology for exactly how we score and weight each factor.
Find foreclosure defense litigation in Islip for your case
No cost, no obligation. Share your situation and we'll connect you with qualified attorneys in your area.
17 businesses, scored on recent reviews. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is foreclosure defense litigation, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.
Reviewers consistently experience a lawyer who listens carefully, explains legal options in plain language, and stays available throughout their case. Mike Schillinger and his office staff treat clients as people rather than cases, answering questions promptly and fighting for results without false promises.
Vincent Campasano and his team earn five-star ratings for real estate closings by staying responsive, patient, and attentive through every step. Buyers and sellers consistently mention his deep experience, clear explanations, and willingness to advocate hard when title companies or buyers create complications. Staff like Chris support clients on nights and weekends, making the process feel manageable even when handled largely online.
Most clients experience swift, attentive legal work with upfront fees and constant updates. Traffic matters, landlord disputes, and family cases move fast under Marra or Shawn Kassman's direct oversight. One older complaint mentions service dropped after a staff member left, but recent reviews (past four months) show strong results and responsiveness across multiple practice areas. Clients praise flat fees, weekend availability, and how the office explains options in plain terms. Communication happens via email, phone, and court handling. Faster-than-expected outcomes and case dismissals are common.
Every review awarded five stars. Clients consistently praise Elaine as knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely caring. She handles real estate closings, divorce mediation, and complicated matters with equal care, walking first-time homebuyers through confusion and catching problems before they become costly ones.
Strong track record across estate, real estate, and personal legal matters. Reviewers consistently note her responsiveness, clarity in explaining legal options, and willingness to prioritize clients' actual interests over billable hours. One bare complaint without detail stands against 22 five-star reviews citing professional advocacy and genuine client care.
Find foreclosure defense litigation in Islip for your case
No cost, no obligation. Share your situation and we'll connect you with qualified attorneys in your area.
Most clients praise Michael Kofsky's attention to detail, availability, and straightforward fees on business formation and real estate work. Two reviews over 2 years old detail serious failures: abandonment during a real estate closing and non-filing in a probate matter despite full payment and eight months of excuses, costing one client over $20,000.
Andrea and her team handle real estate closings with care. Reviewers praise her deep knowledge, quick responses, and readiness to fight for their interests through complex deals and tricky situations.
All reviewers give five stars, citing responsive service, clear knowledge of the work, and genuine attention to clients' concerns. Evidence is limited to four total reviews.
One review praises Jeff Lanzet for managing a complex international divorce involving U.S. and French law with strong attention to detail. Evidence beyond this single case is limited.
Most clients report smooth closings and responsive attorneys. Chanel, Peter Wagner, Andrew LoManto, and Chris Romano are praised for efficiency and knowledge. However, a small group cite missed callbacks, unfiled cases without refunds, and paperwork mistakes years later.
Most reviewers praise Harmel & Associates for responsive service and smooth real estate closings. Staff members Lara and Gloria are frequently named as reliable. However, one detailed complaint describes a $30k wire fraud loss where the firm forwarded unverified banking details and then avoided accountability or insurance claim transparency. Communication broke down entirely after the incident.
Clients consistently praise Robert Macedonio's legal acumen and hands-on approach. He stands out to reviewers for changing outcomes after they fired ineffective prior counsel and delivering results they describe as thorough and committed.
Long-standing clients praise Tom Licari's legal expertise and approachable style, especially on complex deals like 1031 exchanges and home purchases. Recent experience from first-time homebuyers tells a different story: failures to communicate possession date changes left them scrambling for temporary housing and U-Haul extensions, while office staff were reported as impatient and dismissive. The gap between repeat clients and newer ones suggests service quality may depend heavily on deal complexity and client experience level.
Phil Felice's office has secured foreclosure saves and earned gratitude from clients who felt heard and supported. One serious complaint alleges the firm took a retainer, answered one motion in years, failed to update the client, and let a home proceed to auction. That stark contrast warrants direct conversation about case management expectations before hiring.
Five-star reviews praise Adam Mottola and the firm for clear advice, fast document work, and responsive service; one client relied on them for a decade. One-star reviews cite overcharging, slow replies (over a week), and unprofessional dismissal after a client sought other counsel. Review evidence is thin across the stated directory services.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Enquiries submitted through this site's forms may be passed to partner providers who can carry out the work, and the site may receive a referral fee for these introductions. Rankings and scores are based solely on the site's published scoring method and are never affected by referral fees.
Last updated 2026-08-27